Recent comments in /f/todayilearned

ALR3000 t1_j9s7jo9 wrote

Thanks for this. Development of a different language requires relatively prolonged linguistic isolation. With billions of people, broadcast media spreading everywhere, and economic integration around the globe, how is a population going to be relatively isolated? And when firefly isolated populations come in contact.... Well, you get the point

10

Hambredd t1_j9s4z3l wrote

Trenches have been in sieges seen ancient times. The Battle of Alesia, of the siege of Vienna both had stagnant trenches.

Artillery was used like it had been for hundreds of years. Sit a battery on a hill and fire at the enemy you can see. A far cry from the millions of high explosive rounds constantly fired from 20 miles away.

This is just the old american exceptionalism myth , the same is the idea american revolution invented light infantry.

−20

samuelgato t1_j9s4ehf wrote

Not to be a contrarian but what exactly is horrifying? Languages are like species they naturally evolve, grow, decline and become extinct.

I understand that language can be unifying within a culture, but the disappearance of a language seems to be a symptom of cultural homogenization not a cause.

32

emcee_pern t1_j9s3mp7 wrote

The Siege of Petersburg towards the end of the war was nine months of trench warfare that very much looked like an early version of the front lines of WW1.

Also artillery was extremely important during the Civil War. It wasn't as advanced of course but there was still plenty of it having a large impact on battles.

22