Recent comments in /f/television

IndyRevolution t1_ja976b4 wrote

Main issue with Handmaid's Tale is that it feels like there's no driving force in the writer's room. They will start on plotlines and then immediately abandon them an episode later and characters who are set up to be huge players disappear with no explanation. It just seems like they wanna cover a bunch of bases at once and can't actually decide on what the season's "about" (This is the issue I had with the Candyman reboot movie as well).

3

IndyRevolution t1_ja96mht wrote

Legend Of Vox Machina is bogged down by extremely lowbrow and unfunny comedy sequences, as well as rushed pacing (in part due to wasting time with said comedy sequences). Every single time I vocalize this critique, I'm hit with "So...like a DnD game????" (I am not being hyperbolic when I say I get this reply literally every time), which ignores the fact that A: They actively torpedo dramatic moments from the material it adapts for the sake of comedic subversion and B: You do not need to adapt literally every aspect of material and it goes without saying that lowbrow humor is infinitely funnier in improv than it is scripted for a number of reasons.

I stick with it because it has a genuinely good underlying story it's adapting and shows competency in adapting it when it's willing to take itself seriously. If the show hadn't gone with the constant "THIS ISN'T YOUR GRANDAD'S FANTASY SHOW" moments (it literally starts out with a "The Fellowship of the Ring died XD" style scene), then it might even have Invincible levels of good word of mouth and viewership.

5

MGD109 t1_ja96cm1 wrote

I used to have this with Riverdale. The plot went to crazy town after season one (and even before that it was only so good), characters changed each week and it felt like the writers were picking what they were going to do, who liked who, who was sleeping with who, who dies etc. it by throwing darts at list, and overall it was just ridiculously campy.

But to their credit the actors were clearly trying their best with the material available, the cinematography and set design was utterly beautiful well beyond a show of its quality should have any right to be and the action sequences were surprising impressive, and well camp can be kind of fun its own way if you don't take it to seriously.

Then it just got to silly even for that to justify it and I dropped it.

2

Thongs0ng t1_ja94r7u wrote

Prime really wants to break into “prestige” television on the level of HBO, but they’ve never quite been able to make a water-cooler show no matter how much money they throw at it.

The closest they’ve come is The Boys, but even that isn’t on the level of HBO/classic AMC offerings. I wonder what the missing ingredient is.

28

Mathis_Rowan t1_ja94gri wrote

My dad really loved the old TV show... actually loves would be more accurate. He wakes up and watches Perry first thing basically every day. Is there value in this show for him? Or should he just continue and enjoy his nostalgia with the old one? We watched an episode or 2 together and he didn't really like it, but I just read that halfway through they go to more of a lawyer route.

2

SnooDingos316 t1_ja9498b wrote

It is not everyone, just some of "experts judges" of the recent awards shows and I do not think they hate. Probably lots of them never even watch it and others just like the competing shows better.

Actually critics loved it. At the 28th Critics choice awards held in Jan, BCS won Best Drama beating HOTD and Severance.

So it is wrong to say the show did NOT win a single award. It is not true.

Bob Odenkrik won best actor, Giancarlo Esposito won best supporting actor but I agree Rhee Seahorn got screwed over even by the critics.

1