Recent comments in /f/philosophy
str8_rippin123 t1_j4v4y8a wrote
Reply to Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Isn’t this from the guy who wrote a whole book praising enlightenment values? Lol
Saadiqfhs t1_j4v4a3h wrote
Reply to comment by Perrr333 in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | January 16, 2023 by BernardJOrtcutt
Can you extend that to a machine? If you grant a machine the feeling of pain, of love and lose, can it become free?
Similarly, can I create a sub human with same intelligence as a gorilla and make it subservient?
Icy_Collection_1396 t1_j4v3vtx wrote
Reply to comment by WrongAspects in Hume's Guillotine and The Role of Free Speech in Social Media by causeapp
It is true that Reddit's moderators have a great deal of power and control over what is allowed on the platform, and that their decisions are final. However, Reddit does seek to promote free speech. Reddit encourages users to express their opinions, opinions are generally respected and allowed to exist on the platform and Reddit actively works to combat censorship. While Reddit does have rules and moderators that enforce these rules, they seek to create an open, safe platform where users can freely express their opinions without fear of retaliation.
Laser_Fusion t1_j4v3aor wrote
Reply to comment by dsgifj in Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Irrationality is a great defense against people with good arguments and none of your best interest in mind.
K0stroun t1_j4v2vzi wrote
Reply to comment by dsgifj in Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Commitment and apologia riddled with lies and misrepresentations.
antiquemule t1_j4v2my2 wrote
Reply to comment by 1bunch in Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Interesting. Reminds me of the excellent Gerd Gigerenzer's Gut Feelings.
heroicgamer44 t1_j4v1tul wrote
Reply to comment by snoringpuppy5 in Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Precisely. I don’t think most “ ditzy girls” have intelligence in the academic sense (academics are far too egotistical) but I do think they’re incredibly socially intelligent
fjaoaoaoao t1_j4v1so9 wrote
Reply to Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Yes. Our mind regularly occludes information in order to operate. It can become too cognitively taxing otherwise. And in a social world, sometimes trying to be more rational has zero payoff other than for your own pursuit of truth or whatever.
Basically saying what’s already known but I appreciate the different angle.
snoringpuppy5 t1_j4v1mdl wrote
[deleted] t1_j4v1l6o wrote
[deleted] t1_j4v1dh6 wrote
1bunch t1_j4v0ues wrote
Reply to Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Professor Keith Stanovich’s metaphor of the “cognitive miser” made me appreciate how tiring it would be if someone wanted to be truly “rational” and “fully capable” at all times:
>…”we tend to be cognitive misers. When approaching a problem, we can choose from any of several cognitive mechanisms. Some mechanisms have great computational power, letting us solve many problems with great accuracy, but they are slow, require much concentration and can interfere with other cognitive tasks. Others are comparatively low in computational power, but they are fast, require little concentration and do not interfere with other ongoing cognition. Humans are cognitive misers because our basic tendency is to default to the processing mechanisms that require less computational effort, even when they are less accurate.” > >—Source, ‘Scientific American — Rational & Irrational Thought’ by Keith Stanovich
Edit: others have mentioned that this idea is basically the core argument of Daniel Kahneman’s “Thinking Fast & Slow”, but just an FYI Stanovich’s metaphor pre-dates Kahneman’s book , and in that book Kahneman openly says he took some of Stanovich’s terms & was “greatly influenced” by Stanovich’s early writings. Kahneman didn’t steal in some secretive way though, he has given Stanovich a lot of credit & speaks about him as a pioneer.
nixsensei t1_j4v05j9 wrote
Reply to comment by Perrr333 in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | January 16, 2023 by BernardJOrtcutt
Thank you for the reference.
I will have look.
heroicgamer44 t1_j4uybgu wrote
Reply to Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
We see it constantly with reality shows. That kind of performative stupidity can be very useful at concealing someone’s true abilities
dsgifj t1_j4us4l9 wrote
Reply to Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
Explains his commitment to optimism in the face of a social order that seeks to undermine it's ecological survival
cosmotosed t1_j4uqwms wrote
Reply to Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
I was ignorantly incapacitated which caused my irrationality 🫠
WrongAspects t1_j4uodjg wrote
Reply to comment by Icy_Collection_1396 in Hume's Guillotine and The Role of Free Speech in Social Media by causeapp
It’s interesting when you try to apply this to Reddit. In Reddit what you are allowed to say is completely subject to the whims and moods of whichever moderator is reading your post. The moderator is anonymous and their decisions are absolute, final, and not subject to any kind of process before or after the action is taken. They are also completely hidden from the public.
It’s basically censorship by a dictator.
Despite this Reddit sells itself as a free speech platform.
WrongAspects t1_j4uner3 wrote
Reply to comment by Icy_Collection_1396 in The way one experiences freedom changed completely due to technocapitalism by Hour_Director_6330
The irony of reading this on Reddit
meme_ism69 t1_j4umi8r wrote
You can objectively point out at so many things which you could label as "it makes me sad!". But you cannot objectively name one thing that makes you happy in absolutenees.
Masimat t1_j4uh9eo wrote
Is reality 100% deterministic? Determinism says everything has a cause, so the beginning must be uncaused, right? With this reasoning, indeterminism must be true in some aspects of reality.
Icy_Collection_1396 t1_j4uflub wrote
Reply to comment by locri in The way one experiences freedom changed completely due to technocapitalism by Hour_Director_6330
That's too bad, but I guess it's the price of keeping our computers safe!
Capital_Net_6438 t1_j4ufbu5 wrote
Reply to comment by Perrr333 in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | January 16, 2023 by BernardJOrtcutt
Well put. It’s nice to have a place to practice philosophy (to some extent) as opposed to just telling someone what views are out there.
EducatorBig6648 t1_j4uezqh wrote
Reply to comment by Embarrassed_Honey606 in Philosophy has never been the detached pursuit of truth. It’s always been deeply invested in its own cultural perspective. by IAI_Admin
You're welcome. I'm curious how you imagine the history of dictionaries, though, if you think negatively of what I've said about them.
Capital_Net_6438 t1_j4uepfs wrote
Reply to comment by JofisKat in /r/philosophy Open Discussion Thread | January 16, 2023 by BernardJOrtcutt
I suppose you don’t consider doing the dishes a real accomplishment? I guess I have lowered my expectations with age.
Bl4nkface t1_j4v5bdu wrote
Reply to comment by 1bunch in Steven Pinker on the power of irrationality | Choosing ignorance, incapacity, or irrationality can at times be the most rational thing to do. by IAI_Admin
That's the argument of Daniel Kahneman's Thinking fast and slow.