Recent comments in /f/personalfinance

Beachboo07 OP t1_j6iyibr wrote

$600 into a HYSA at 3.75%. I want to reach around $20k and then I want to start investing. I do have some money in my 401k, Roth and a brokerage but I stopped investing in order to put more towards my loans a few months ago. I’m saving as an emergency fund, even though it’s a bit higher than normal it eases my anxiety to have it on hand.

Yes, $3400 is the net pay after all taxes and benefits. I am currently on my parents dental and health so I’m fortunate to not pay that until I am 26.

2

poke0003 t1_j6iy8ud wrote

All investment is risk based - that’s why the basis for comparison is the risk free rate of return (which is really conceptual but commonly US T-Notes and T-Bills are used). Since FDIC insured account are extremely low risk, they have lower return. If there is a competing yield 259 bps higher (or even 89 bps higher), it presumably comes with either greater risk or maybe is not a similar cash equivalent investment. Certainly one difference is that it could be denominated in a less desirable/useful currency than USD. It could also be that the non-US account they have it in lacks protection equivalent to FDIC insurance (so more risk).

Again though, the key factor is that not all yields are directly comparable. No financial institution gives away a free 289 bps with zero strings attached. If your non-us SA gets 5.89%, it is very likely that either currency differences or risk exposure or both are why. This is different from comparing the rate across competing US HYSA, which I believe is what was being questioned.

So to recap:

  1. we all agree commenter is not using us savings accounts.
  2. at least I am proposing that they are getting 5.89% on their money because their instruments are not equivalent to US savings accounts.
  3. investing your year of rent money in assets materially riskier than HYSA is a choice one could make, but doesn’t really seem in the spirit of the original comments.

This concludes my TED talk.

<Wild applause from the gallery>

1

Lopsided_Law_6258 t1_j6ixg1l wrote

Keep in mind that ally bank has a daily outbound transfer limit of 10k for new customers less 90 days. I believe this is for ACH only and can get around with wires.

1

CookieAdventure t1_j6iwqm2 wrote

I don’t know which deployment port you’ll be in, but all sorts of things can happen while it is in storage, especially if you’re on the gulf or east coast. Your insurance should drop because you won’t be driving it but it still needs to be covered for damage. Ask a mechanic what you have to do to store it properly if you can’t leave it with someone who can drive it occasionally.

1

CookieAdventure t1_j6iuysp wrote

You won’t need a vehicle when you’re on a sub but you won’t be at sea for the entire 2 years. You do get a break. You can store the vehicle. Yes, it was a stupid purchase but, if you can’t afford to sell it now, your option is to store it and pay down the loan. The upside is once you get access to it again, it’ll be really low mileage for its age.

11