Recent comments in /f/personalfinance

zhentarim_agent t1_j2cm5u4 wrote

Absolutely not. What happens if you get laid off or budget cuts are made? When commission doesn't come in for a few months?

There's way too much risk here when you're stuck in a year long lease.

What about all the furniture you'll need? Monthly utilities? Renter's insurance? All the other little things start to add up once you move out.

29

Mysunsai t1_j2cm09e wrote

The answer, formally, is that the IRS has not yet issued any ruling on that problem, and so nobody actually knows whether that could become a problem.

The practical answer is that it is so easy to find alternatives that still have essentially perfect correlation, that it is not really worth taking a risk on it.

6

dequeued t1_j2clxk1 wrote

If only timing the market was that easy. Your best bet is to ignore the noise and follow the steps in the Prime Directive.

More on market timing:

Remember that you're investing for the next 30-40 years, not trying to predict the Dow next week, next month, or next year.

3

dequeued t1_j2cl6n2 wrote

> would let you effectively contribute more (if you want to) because you are contributing with after-tax money

This is really the wrong way to think about this (basically, what you're saying is at best technically true).

  1. You're ignoring the tax savings from contributing to a Traditional that result in more income which can then be invested, used to pay down debt, etc. Only if you spend it on ephemeral stuff does that money "disappear".

  2. The goal with the "Roth vs. Traditional" decision should really be made based on whatever nets you the most money to spend in retirement. For most high earners, that's almost certainly Traditional. Read Roth or Traditional for a longer discussion.

(tagging /u/hankmoody666)

1

arpatel530 t1_j2cl4ws wrote

Max out 401k. Put every other $ for house into hysa at 4% and don't play with it. Every other $ that is free use in a taxable account and start buying schd. Don't complicate things.

Your goal right now is to maximize earnings thru your job. That's where the bulk of your early to mid career wealth will come from. The late part of your wealth will be from assets and equities that you built up over time.

3

maedocc t1_j2cl2bk wrote

>I’m 24 years old and make $110K

Traditional makes sense for high income earners like you.

> A few thousand in extra savings by using the traditional would help, but my house savings would not really require this as I’m quickly reaching my goal of $100K for a down payment.

You can take the extra thousands in savings, toss it into a regular brokerage account and let it ride in VOO. More invested is always better.

2