Recent comments in /f/history
ghunt81 t1_j02vtzd wrote
Reply to Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
I feel like this happens every time a hurricane hits the east coast of Florida. Hell I remember an old wooden ship being uncovered after one of the hurricanes at a beach near my grandparent's house. Hurricane Andrew maybe?
[deleted] t1_j02ucf2 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j02tnou wrote
Reply to comment by tree-molester in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j02t5c3 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j02sxm6 wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[removed]
Emotional_Dare5743 t1_j02re62 wrote
Reply to Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
Florida is festooned with wrecks and buried debris. Many of the folks that lived in Florida during the 1800s and early 1900s built entire houses out of the wreckage of ships and cargo. In the late 1800s the US government even established a series of outposts up the entire East coast of Florida for shipwrecked mariners. They were spaced out in such a way that a sailor wouldn't have to walk more than 5 or 10 miles in any direction without coming to one. The Gulf Stream parallels the East coast of Florida. It was a superhighway of trade during the colonial era and is still a busy body of water.
War_Hymn t1_j02pdqn wrote
Reply to comment by Regulai in How many knights in Armor would be on a battle field? by autism_guy_69
And even when these peasant-based military forces did exist, the people fielding them eventually realize they were not ideal when fighting had to be done away from the homeland or for an extended time, and start to establish smaller but better trained/equipped forces to replace or supplement them. We see that transition happen in the Heian period of Japan (which saw the rise of the samurai warrior class) and Eastern Han in China.
In the case of early Republican Rome, a free citizen had to have wealth and property amounting to at least 150 drachmae (a silver drachmae at the time amounted to one day's wages for a skilled labourer) to be even considered for military service.
Even with the English archers in the Hundred Years War, most were middle-class gentry/well-to-do peasantry who had the means and income to afford their own military equipment and time to train for war/fight on extended campaign. Or were part of a noble's military retinue who was provided with equipment and income by their liege. With the latter, it'll be rather poor standing for a noble at the time to bring a band of poorly armed, rag-tattered peasants to a fight instead of a loyal/trusted, well-equipped and trained band of retainers.
BonesOfTheWaywardSon OP t1_j02o1m6 wrote
Reply to comment by ThatGIRLkimT in An essay on The Harlan County War by BonesOfTheWaywardSon
Thanks!
War_Hymn t1_j02m3xj wrote
Reply to comment by Norumbega-GameMaster in How many knights in Armor would be on a battle field? by autism_guy_69
>And the idea that life had little meaning is just not accurate.
I mean for one, peasants were valuable as agricultural workers on a medieval noble's estate. It seems unwise to throw their lives away in battle when they could better used at home tending the crops and making you income.
hiriel t1_j02k6cj wrote
Reply to comment by polymercat420 in Medieval ship found in Norway‘s biggest lake by J4tune1860
There was no Tudor era in Norway, as we don't have any Tudors...
The medieval era in Norways is commonly said to end with the reformation of 1537.
polymercat420 t1_j02i2l9 wrote
Reply to comment by CaesuraRepose in Medieval ship found in Norway‘s biggest lake by J4tune1860
Yeah didn't the medieval era end in 1450 and then the Tudor era started?
[deleted] t1_j02hqcf wrote
Reply to An Investigation into Vlad Tepes by MiguelPolimatus
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j02g62o wrote
Reply to comment by Epistatious in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[deleted]
tree-molester t1_j02etmt wrote
Reply to Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
I love the woman/girl digging with flip-flops. Serious excavation here. Although I guess they wore slides when building the pyramids.
[deleted] t1_j02ecmx wrote
Reply to Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[removed]
Karvier OP t1_j02e4jq wrote
Reply to I have translated some letters between the khans of Mongolian and Manchus recorded in the Manchus literary sources, pretty funny how they were roasting each other. by Karvier
Btw: I have to cut irrelevant parts from the Manchus’ reply to make it fit the post, that letter was so lengthy!
ehunke t1_j02cosj wrote
Reply to comment by Alpcake in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Our long history of respect and dignity twords indigenous lands...
[deleted] t1_j02bqt4 wrote
[removed]
Epistatious t1_j02b34e wrote
Reply to comment by WilliamWhit in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
Looks like its within tide zone? Will be expensive to excavate. Might just be a whaler or fishing boat.
Two-Hard-Sticks t1_j02b2a4 wrote
Reply to comment by RiceAlicorn in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
I don’t think they are looking for a specific answer for this question. I think they are looking for any answer. If you wanted to specify the max distance of a Portuguese style bola, from a specific time period, I’m sure they would be happy with the answer.
WilliamWhit t1_j029xbz wrote
Reply to Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
I’m sorry, but expensive or not, we’re not gonna take the chance and look for treasure in the spooky washed up ship?!
That’s just crazy.
fuckpudding t1_j027hes wrote
Reply to comment by MedonSirius in Medieval ship found in Norway‘s biggest lake by J4tune1860
Is the detective Cheems from dogelore?
Lagiacrus111 t1_j026pz1 wrote
Reply to comment by ccReptilelord in Medieval ship found in Norway‘s biggest lake by J4tune1860
I know this is a meme comment but this is like absolutely false.
t-m t1_j0260e5 wrote
Reply to comment by znoopyz in Medieval ship found in Norway‘s biggest lake by J4tune1860
Wasn't the Vasa completely forgotten about for 200+ years before it was found and dredged?
[deleted] t1_j02xvgo wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in Hurricanes Reveal 19th-Century Shipwreck Hidden Beneath Florida Beach by That-Situation-4262
[removed]