Recent comments in /f/history

MAD6658 t1_j2qjfcd wrote

I can't say that I agree. I've been to dozens of shows on and off Broadway, and I'd be hard pressed to tell the difference between a live orchestra and a high quality recording.

0

SocialMediaMakesUSad t1_j2qerlm wrote

I can clearly understand how they weren't designed that way, but what makes it difficult to play? Don't they play regular concerts that are that long with no breaks or one break in the middle?

4

Elegyjay t1_j2qazba wrote

A friend of mine in the TV & movie business points out that now the same fight is being waged over possible AI production of entire movies and TV properties with NO actors or voice-overs or live production resources.

1

GargantuanGorgon t1_j2q9npm wrote

I'm kind of curious to see some epic film like gladiator prepared for orchestra accompaniment, but with no orchestra. Like, the whole film without music. You never get to see finished films like that and I'd be interested to see just exactly how much you lose (I'm guessing a lot).

3

GargantuanGorgon t1_j2q9fwt wrote

Oh man that's epic. When the Rohirrim arrive at Helm's Deep, goosebumps. And then Return of the King, the ending, fuggedaboudit, there won't be a dry eye in the house.

2

sluuuurp t1_j2pw02g wrote

That’s probably because you knew it was live, not just because the sound was different. Music isn’t just about the sounds our ears hear, it’s also about the context and our state of mind when we hear it.

0

WilliamMorris420 t1_j2pvsi2 wrote

From the wiki page of The Jazz Singer linked in the article.

>On January 1, 2023, The Jazz Singer's U.S. copyright expired, when all works published in 1927 entered the public domain.

Steamboat Willie came out in 1928. Which was the first ever appearence of Mickey Mouse. Which Disney is going to hate.

1

ilvostro t1_j2pssq5 wrote

I'd heard Star Spangled Banner a hundred times in my life and felt absolutely no emotion whatsoever, but the very first time I heard it played by a live symphony orchestra I was crying by the sixth note. There's a difference.

2

JacobDCRoss t1_j2pqfm8 wrote

Here in Portland they did at least one showing of some of the old Superman cartoons. The showing featured (IIRC) live music, and it also had some local personalities doing the voice work live.

3