Recent comments in /f/history
[deleted] t1_j1jsbsr wrote
Reply to comment by NovelCandid in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
[removed]
ShunyShock t1_j1jrtpo wrote
Reply to comment by woodrax in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
I don’t agree with the merciful beheadings, but the rest seems very nice, and the guy that banned them, probably smells like hot dog water! :)
ideonode t1_j1jrhdv wrote
Reply to comment by TheBeefofLove in Bookclub Wednesday! by AutoModerator
Have you read The Last Duel by Eric Jager? It's the book on which the film was based. I preferred the book, as it provides more context than the film.
[deleted] t1_j1jqehg wrote
Reply to comment by edgy_secular_memes in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
[removed]
Thibaudborny t1_j1jqbd0 wrote
Reply to comment by swornds8261 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
No, also consider that for most of its existence, it was never even a non-stop barrier, but rather a collection of. The emblematic wall you know today was the product of the Ming dynasty, by which point the era of migrations was at its end.
jezreelite t1_j1jq4mi wrote
Reply to comment by edgy_secular_memes in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Virginia Rounding puts that rumor down to three factors:
- The scholar and traveler Adam Ölschläger had claimed in the mid-17th century that Russians liked sleeping with horses and his claims became sort of an in-joke in Western Europe.
- Catherine loved horse riding.
- Catherine wasn't married throughout her reign, but still had a vigorous sex life with her various favourites.
Thibaudborny t1_j1jq1uv wrote
Reply to comment by 19Backrooms93 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
Who said he turned his back on his beliefs? On the contrary, he was going to force his beliefs on everyone, you know, for their own good. The road to hell and good intentions, you know.
PolymerSledge t1_j1jpozd wrote
PolymerSledge t1_j1jpo8n wrote
[deleted] t1_j1jpdsq wrote
Reply to Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
[removed]
JayneLut t1_j1jougl wrote
Reply to comment by paul_is_on_reddit in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
Which is odd, because he effectively banned all the fun things about Christmas... Like singing and getting merry. He didn't ban going to church (though no special services!) or quietly reading the Bible on the day.
TheBattler t1_j1jorq0 wrote
Reply to comment by Type31971 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
>wheeled carts being drawn by humans have existed in Europe and Asia for centuries, if not millennia.
Okay but that doesn't matter when our earliest archaeological evidence for carts is often tied to cattle; the Brononice pot abstractly depicts a wagon and was found alongside the remains of an auroch. Tripolye culture toy bull is literally a bull on wheels. Evidence for carts and wagons appear in present-day Ukraine just after the introduction of cattle.
It's a boring answer but for whatever reason, humans didn't think they needed a cart until they had some other poor animal to drag it around.
practically_floored t1_j1jodx4 wrote
Reply to comment by paul_is_on_reddit in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
Generally the rule is when there's a question for a headline, the answer is normally no
Laura-ly t1_j1jn703 wrote
Reply to comment by ukexpat in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
I think it was a typo....he meant to say "floundered" America.
ThoseThingsAreWeird t1_j1jlabo wrote
Reply to comment by y0m0tha in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
elmonoenano t1_j1jl3zc wrote
Reply to comment by Dutchie-4-ever in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
I've never heard that phrase. They're some superficial similarities, but they were very different individuals, in very different contexts, doing very different things. Can you point us to where you heard the term?
TheBattler t1_j1jkub9 wrote
Reply to comment by swornds8261 in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
The Great Wall didn't really prevent people from crossing into China, it was more of an early detection system than a true barrier. The Steppe pastures that horse nomads want extend westward, so it was a natural channel for them to go that way.
Pastoralists like the Scythians had been making regular crossings into Europe through the Danubefor centuries before the Great Wall.
The real impetus for crossing into China, and thus the reason for the Great Wall, was to take over parts of a rich civilization. That was a regular occurrence even with the Great Wall in place. When Steppe conquerors noticed new goods being traded from a rich civilization at the other end of the world like Rome, they migrated in that direction.
Ojjuiceman2772 t1_j1jkomv wrote
Truth is most soldiers used spears which was a lot cheaper and much more effective. Those with swords useally brought their own or had a specialized reason on why they needed a sword and not a spear but if you were just a random Roman soldier you almost always got a spear as your main weapon.
clig73 t1_j1jklnh wrote
Reply to comment by Muffinshire in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
Then he founded the New Model Army, and praise be!, beat the Cavaliers at Naisby, and the King fled up North, like a bat to the Scots.
elmonoenano t1_j1jk78h wrote
Reply to comment by MewMimo in Simple/Short/Silly History Questions Saturday! by AutoModerator
A lot of the terms in your question are very general and it's not clear what you mean. Sin is pretty clear, but what do you mean by better? You need to put what kind of metric you're using to mean better. If you're just looking at straight up numbers, sure, lots of other leaders have caused the deaths of more people.
But that's not the only thing that's measured when people claim that Hitler was uniquely awful. People look at how much destruction he caused, the time frame in which he did it, Stalin for instance was in power almost 3 times longer than Hitler yet didn't create a European wide catastrophe on par with WWII. Mao was in power for even longer, if you include his leadership of the CCP during the revolution.
You can also look at who the various other contenders killed, and except for Hitler, it was mostly their political enemies, or people who were thought to be enemies. Hitler killed a lot of people just b/c they were there. There's no Maoist or Stalinest equivalent of murdering the majority of the Slavic people for lebensraum. Neither Stalin nor Mao had any philosophy that required the total eradication of groups like Jews and Roma. Stalin and Mao generally killed people b/c of what they did or might do, not b/c of who they were.
You can also look at where they killed. Most of the other contenders were killing people within their own political entities. Hitler rampaged across all of Europe and North Africa, far outside the borders of Germany and Austria.
There's also the impact on what Hitler did to his own countryman. It wasn't just the military that was out killing people. He involved the whole society in the process, from the railroad workers shipping people to camps, to people who were given stolen property of Jewish people, to every business (which was almost every manufacturing concern of any size) that used slave labor. Under Nazism, it wasn't just the military, secret police, and political operatives. It was everyone.
[deleted] t1_j1jjr0s wrote
Reply to comment by paul_is_on_reddit in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
[removed]
smon696 t1_j1jj6bw wrote
Reply to Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
Don't know but he banned the Irish, sadly.
[deleted] t1_j1jiy60 wrote
Reply to Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
[removed]
y0m0tha t1_j1jhon0 wrote
Reply to comment by paul_is_on_reddit in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
Whenever media is titled with a question, the answer is basically always “No”
[deleted] t1_j1jssw3 wrote
Reply to comment by smon696 in Did Oliver Cromwell Ban Christmas? by Brattonismybae
[removed]