Recent comments in /f/gifs

DasMotorsheep t1_j6d5dc3 wrote

Reply to comment by Straightup32 in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

It's quite simple:

This kind of statistic can't prove anything because you're only looking at a certain type of outcome. You're not recording how many cats die on impact.

Example:Say you throw 100 cats out of a 5th story window, and 50 survive without harm, 20 die and 30 get sent to the vet with various degrees of injuries. End result: 100 falls, 30 hospitalizations.

Now you throw 100 cats out of a 15th story window - 20 survive without harm, 70 die and 10 get sent to the vet. End result 100 falls, 10 hospitalizations.

If you only look at "number of total falls vs hospitalizations", it would seem that falls from the 15th story are safer.

It's also quite a strange claim that 4-5 stories high isn't enough time for the cat to prepare itself for impact when they can actually right themselves within like a meter and change of free fall, as countless cat videos on the internet will show.

1

DasMotorsheep t1_j6d4hfm wrote

Reply to comment by bremidon in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

I don't know man. If a child can hold a cat in their arms belly up, drop it and the cat will land feet-first, I somehow doubt that "a couple of stories high" is somehow not enough time for the cat to right itself and prepare for the impact.

−2

mattot999 t1_j6d48wv wrote

Reply to comment by bremidon in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Are you implying an expert may be better informed on a topic relevant to them? I bet you'll tell me something silly like I should consider their opinion on the matter /s

3

lefthandedgun t1_j6czwrp wrote

Reply to comment by bremidon in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

If he was adamant about that, Dr. Garvey is a pompous twit who knows next to nothing about statistics...and everything else merely demonstrates that while they might sometimes survive, cats clearly don't make jumps of such heights safely.

−3

lefthandedgun t1_j6cyxx2 wrote

Reply to comment by ghigoli in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Put down the pipe; that shit's making you delusional. No cat would intentionally attempt that jump unless motivated by fear to escape some perceived threat. The height is too extreme, and definitely exceeds what one would routinely execute safely.

32

smashteapot t1_j6csm1f wrote

Reply to 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

I like the marble floors. I know it’s probably a hotel, but it’s nice. I wish I had interior decorating skills.

−1

emowgli t1_j6cmbfe wrote

Reply to comment by Spyger9 in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Many predators have their own predators, unless they are apex predators. And animals are opportunistic, they take advantage of vulnerabilities of others.

9

Yay_for_Pickles t1_j6ck71d wrote

Reply to comment by Spyger9 in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Our vet told this to me when my cat seemed to have had a stroke. He was fine in the morning, then was a hot mess a few hours later.

He was actually in kidney failure, for a while, and showed no signs of illness, apparently for this reason. I was surprised, too.

11