Recent comments in /f/gifs

bremidon t1_j6ci3p6 wrote

Reply to comment by Thr0w-a-gay in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

I followed the links to the original sources.

Your first one comes from "The Straight Dope". It's an entertaining place for odd facts, but I would not treat it as a primary source. In any case, when we read about Cecil's attempts to clear the matter, we eventually reach this point:

>I called the Animal Medical Center to see if this possibility had been considered. The original authors were long gone, so I spoke to Dr. Michael Garvey, head of the medical department and current expert on “high-rise syndrome.”

Dr. Garvey was adamant that the omission of nonreported fatalities didn’t skew the statistics. He pointed out that cats that had fallen from great heights typically had injuries suggesting they’d landed on their chests, which supports the “flying squirrel” hypothesis.

So while technically true that this point was raised in the not-entirely-primary-source article, it was pretty much dismissed by the expert interviewed for that same article. When pressed, apparently Dr. Garvey allowed that reasonable people could disagree, but the fact that the expert falls on the "it's wrong" side, this point should probably be taken with suspicious eyes.

Your second one is more interesting. There have been different studies over the years and in some of them, we do get reports of more serious injuries in cats falling from higher places. In others, there is a dramatic decrease in injuries. As far as I was able to gather in a cursory look through the data, this is still a completely open question as to which data is more representative. Perhaps someone has a metastudy on this.

The nature of the injuries changes dramatically, though. At higher distances, cats can prepare themselves, get righted, and loosen up their legs for landing. The injuries tend to be more in their chest cavity. At shorter distances, the injuries tend to be more of the "broken limb" variety.

8

Xytakis t1_j6chanr wrote

Reply to 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Classic Adrenalin junkie, spreading his legs to slow down to get the most of the jump.

1

bremidon t1_j6cgu5y wrote

Reply to comment by Spyger9 in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Correct. They are not apex predators, so they have to keep their heads on a swivel and check their 6; but not only are the predators, they are obligate carnivores.

Cats are notable for how well they can hide pain. I would be curious if there are other animals that do this as well or better than cats, because I am not aware of any.

25

ghigoli t1_j6cb8wx wrote

Reply to comment by unholyfire in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

no lives were wasted in that jump lol. cats know how to jump from heights that high up. its a special thing going with its core muscles and legs + making themselves parachute in a way.

−10

Spyger9 t1_j6c7e9u wrote

Reply to comment by selfishcaboose in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Also there's just this tiny little thing that we might consider in such a discussion about the nature o- THEY EAT MEAT WITH THEIR BIG POINTY TEETH!!!

XD

10

selfishcaboose t1_j6c5v6g wrote

Reply to comment by Spyger9 in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Even their eye shape makes them predator. Prey animals have a wider field of vision with sideways pupils. Predators have the vertical for help in depth perception and light capture. Ofc it's not for all of either but generally if it's forward set eyes and round or vertical slit it's a predator. Just best for hunting moving prey.

5

spidermonkey301 t1_j6c4xtx wrote

Reply to 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

The way the cat is moving before the jump and also the tail seems down and fluffy. Seems like it was already stressed or spooked before it yeeted itself over the edge.

144

Spyger9 t1_j6c3zki wrote

Reply to comment by Yay_for_Pickles in 9 lives by PewPewAnimeGirl

Hilarious in a couple ways:

  1. If we're classifying animals as one or the other, cats are absolutely predators.

  2. You're suggesting that animals don't want to appear vulnerable because they are prey, which implies that predators operate differently.

Not saying your advice is bad, but the logic seems pretty shoddy.

42