Recent comments in /f/books

kornychris2016 t1_jdi52ow wrote

The answer to "why can't that human race also be diverse like it is in real life "

It's not real life. It's fantasy. A story made up in somebody's head.

Again, the author writes what they want to write. If you don't like a particular story because because it lacks diversity according to your ideology, find an author who shares the same, or write your own.

I'm all for a more diverse world. Instead of white washing or black washing and what not. I think a epic fantasy tale today would most likely include what you desire. But the works that any fantasy is inspired by is simply a product of its time.

It's just completely situational. There is no always right or always wrong in this matter.

But to answer the OP question of the logic, it's simple. Whoever wrote it, can write what they want. It's their imagination.

2

Beautiful-Cat-1519 t1_jdi2v4e wrote

5 stars: It caused some kind of emotional response. E.g. I cried, or I just loved it so much I hugged it at the end.

4 stars: It was good, I enjoyed it.

3 stars: It was okay. I got through it.

I never rate anything below 3 stars because if a book is that bad I'll put it down before finishing it.

1

AwHellNawFetaCheese t1_jdi0p78 wrote

You put out a negative review about something and got flamed for it, you’re not minding your own business you’re inviting that conflict.

Does it in any way excuse their actions and comments? Not at all but don’t share publicly if you can’t handle the blowback.

4

ItsBoughtnotBrought t1_jdhza94 wrote

Well, it's not real for a start. Maybe focus on how devoid of sadness your own life is to be this affected by book or on the flip side, delve into whatever real grief you're carrying around in real-life that was brought out by something you connected to in the book.

8

LooseDoctor t1_jdhz911 wrote

It’s wild to me how many people in these comments think the only people that use tiktok are teenagers. My FYP is exclusively older adults. It’s just a social media app, there’s no max age limit for using it lmao.

2

LooseDoctor t1_jdhz1c1 wrote

Reply to comment by Superb-Draft in Toxic book fans by sunforthemoon

Agreed, it’s happened to me on Reddit! It made me not want to participate in book discussions at all on here. Anyone that thinks Reddit is somehow a better version of social media just cause it’s their favorite needs to do some introspection.

13

sisharil t1_jdhy4ff wrote

In such a setting there shouldn't be any white people, as pale skin didn't develop until fairly recently.

Lol, why is this getting downvoted? If you are so concerned with realism and logic, you have to understand that the only setting where people haven't traveled far enough away from one another for long enough to develop different racial attributes is one where white people have never come into existence.

People down voting this are REALLY not helping their case that they totally aren't racists for hating diversity in books.

−6