Recent comments in /f/books

loneacer t1_ja7nwpn wrote

I finished it over the weekend. I've read all but about 10 of his full length novels. Eventually I'll read them all. I'd put The Shining somewhere in the bottom 25%, maybe even bottom 10%. I think he really shines with books that are heavy on fantasy. Horror books, books that are just trying to be scary with a thin plot, aren't enjoyable for me.

I thought Fairy Tale was fine. Not great, but somewhere solidly in the middle of his catalog. The sex paragraph kind of came out of the blue and didn't fit in very well, but it is what it is. Up until then, I kind of expected the two female prisoners to be lesbians, or if not I thought Charlie might hook up with Jaya since they interacted a lot throughout the story.

−2

HugoNebula t1_ja7nfuy wrote

>My first was the shining, which i would rate a 8/10. So maybe, King is just not my style and i was lucky with the shining.

I think you could pick any of King's first half-dozen or so books (and all of the initial Richard Bachman novels) and have a pretty good time, rewarding your time and interest. After that, maybe another half-dozen equally strong reads, as long as you avoided the novels veering into fantasy (and I would include the Dark Tower series in this).

Fairy Tale comes in the twilight of a very long career, when most folk would just retire. King can't not write, so he'll continue to be published, but he's written very little of real worth—certainly compared to his heyday—for almost two decades now.

2

spotted-cat t1_ja7n5ki wrote

I agree that YA novels are too soft, but I blame the conservative pearlclutchers. I mean, have you seen what’s happening in Texas and Florida? Every time I pick up a queer YA book its full of bad jokes and I feel like I’m being preached at. Everyone wants to make sure the childrens’ feelings are never hurt, so they write about an imaginary rainbow fantasyland where nothing ever really goes wrong. And the MCs never struggle for longer than a nanosecond before everything is magically fixed.

2

anythingbuttaken t1_ja7lui8 wrote

I’m the same way. I can listen to simple “summer reads” but if I’m going to try to absorb a subject to learn or understand I have to read them or listen while doing almost nothing else. My audiobooks are all books where you could skip a chapter and not really miss it. Stuff to understand is words on paper/iPad and stored next to my stereo.

1

Nemesis0408 t1_ja7lmy2 wrote

The reader is supposed to worry for a while that

  1. Jane is only being swept away by a strong personality with Mr. Rochester, and
  2. her religious beliefs are going to overwhelm her in her grief, and keep her from balance and happiness

Her relationship with St. John shows us that when tested, she’s going to stand up for herself on both fronts. Knowing that makes us feel much better about her returning to Rochester. St. John should have been the perfect thing to break her spirit and he wasn’t. Knowing that she also has money and family to fall back on now and she STILL chooses Rochester show us she’s also not just looking for security.

I agree that the pacing gets a little slow in the third act, but it’s almost all relevant. As for the religious adherence, all I can say is that it was written in another time, when those things were of real concern to most people.

8

boxer_dogs_dance t1_ja7l0ft wrote

So honestly you should take your request to r/fantasy and r/printsf and r/suggestmeabook.

Publishing is a business and is subject to trends and the demands of the market. There is a wide range and variety of what you are looking for in older books, not all of them in realist settings from other Centuries. Although as a fan of historical adventure in particular, I think you are missing out.

The Deed of Paksenarrion has what you are looking for. I am currently loving the Lions of Al Rassan which has a character who matches your request learning to work with adults. It's an amazing book.

2

SneezlesForNeezles t1_ja7kigl wrote

I have a few methods;

  • Goodreads; I’ve been doing this since 2015 consistently, so keep it up to date. I can see basic stats and track books. I try to review every book.
  • Storygraph; Migrated my data last year. They have pretty graphs.
  • Notebooks; I have a notebook where I list the books straight for quote taking purposes (noted below), and the other half of the notebook is used for to read book lists.
  • Quote taking; Since about… 2006? I’ve taken quotes from books. I now have 17 odd notebooks full of my favourite quotes from every book I’ve ever read. These I will admit are my pride and joy! I’m currently a tad behind, which is why I have my hand written list so I can easily access the next book.
  • Book Journal; I haven’t done this in a while but I have a book journal which I fill in for favourite books. I try to draw an image for each book along with the brief review. This is the Moleskine book journal.
1