Recent comments in /f/askscience
blujaibeauvais t1_j9hntol wrote
Reply to comment by PJHFortyTwo in What are more accepted hypotheses that similarly explain the aspects of hominid evolution that the "pseudoscientific" aquatic ape theory does? by KEVLAR60442
The idea that humans evolved because of our bums seems reasonable. Our butts allowed us to become good at distance, running that we would out - endurance animals sprinting away during hunting until the prey eventually gave up. Having more calories and then fire to unleash those calories or hypothesized in some circles to be a major change in our development
Marsdreamer t1_j9hniym wrote
Reply to comment by CletusDSpuckler in What are more accepted hypotheses that similarly explain the aspects of hominid evolution that the "pseudoscientific" aquatic ape theory does? by KEVLAR60442
Evolution is honestly a lot more nuanced than people generally realize. Even deleterious mutations and traits can rise to fixation in a population despite our understanding of fitness models.
Marsdreamer t1_j9hn9fl wrote
Reply to comment by KEVLAR60442 in What are more accepted hypotheses that similarly explain the aspects of hominid evolution that the "pseudoscientific" aquatic ape theory does? by KEVLAR60442
Adding to this, no evolutionary biologists look at traits in organisms today and explain how / why they evolved by how they are beneficial. To do so is teleogical, explanation by the purpose they serve rather than the process by which they came to be. It also ignores that sometimes traits serve no actual purpose. They can arise to fixation randomly or the trait is vestigial for some other functions that are no longer relevant, but now serve a different purpose. A good example is that, in the case of human hairlessness, the reason why is still actually a pretty hotly debated subject because we don't really know.
Generally speaking, in order to confirm a trait's purpose and evolution you have to study the impact on fitness when you remove that trait and you have to use nearest relatives or most common ancestors to show how the trait evolved in the model species in question.
CompleteNumpty t1_j9hn73i wrote
Reply to comment by natgibounet in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
As a significant quantity of amputations (maybe even most) aren't a result of trauma, but due to things like diabetes or peripheral vascular disease, a lot of amputees will already be getting treated/monitored for heart disease, which will muddy the waters.
I tried to find a source for you, but I struggled to find anything other than a few studies confirming the increased risk in traumatic amputation patients.
[deleted] t1_j9hn47d wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j9hmsdc wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j9hml84 wrote
[deleted] t1_j9hmhmu wrote
[deleted] t1_j9hme6e wrote
natgibounet t1_j9hma2j wrote
Reply to comment by CompleteNumpty in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
I should look into it, i'm surprised i never heard that even though i live in a western european country
Ronaldoooope t1_j9hm0ab wrote
Reply to comment by bonerfiedmurican in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
In a lot of cases the reason they got an amputation was decreased blood flow (diabetics) so they likely just normalize in that case lol
Krail t1_j9hlwx4 wrote
Reply to comment by Georgie___Best in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
This is making me realize a question I didn't know I had about the circulatory system.
How do the "delivery" vessels connect back to the "return to the heart" vessels? Does blood come out from the capillaries and then get taken up by other capillaries?
LogicJunkie2000 t1_j9hlrue wrote
Reply to comment by RuhrowSpaghettio in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
I vaguely remember the aid training shifting in the late oughts from a kinda checklist/hierarchy of things to do before applying a tourniquet into something close to "when in doubt if they might need a tourniquet, put a tourniquet on it."
Aside from the reasons you gave, I think it probably came down to the fact that there was an expectation that you would be getting treated by an expert in a hospital or purpose-fitted vehicle within an hour (whenever life/limb/eyesight was in jeopardy)
I have a lot of mixed feelings about my country and my service, but am still very impressed/proud of the extreme lengths the medical corps and supporting units went through to make MEDEVACs and treatment such a priority.
CompleteNumpty t1_j9hl0av wrote
Reply to comment by natgibounet in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
I was just going off what my old prosthetics lecturer told us, but the UK and USA definitely do. The exact action taken (preventative medication and exercise programmes vs routine monitoring of cardiac function) may differ within the countries due to different states, health boards etc.
To be honest I'd be amazed if any Western country didn't have some sort of policy to monitor or preventatively treat amputees, as the increased risk of heart disease is well-known.
ExaltHolderForPoE t1_j9hkzv1 wrote
Reply to comment by kelroe26 in What are more accepted hypotheses that similarly explain the aspects of hominid evolution that the "pseudoscientific" aquatic ape theory does? by KEVLAR60442
With knowledge like these, OP doesnt go to parties..... parties goes to him.
[deleted] t1_j9hkzms wrote
[deleted] t1_j9hkufe wrote
Reply to comment by [deleted] in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j9hksrt wrote
Dalenonne t1_j9hk9ug wrote
Reply to comment by CoastalPizza in Why can’t mules reproduce? by Imaginary_Camel4213
Is it like male down syndrome people are sterile and females have difficulty combining with 'normals' contribution?
[deleted] t1_j9hk2av wrote
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j9hjpsn wrote
[deleted] t1_j9hjhz2 wrote
ToastyTheDragon t1_j9hj129 wrote
Reply to comment by Ausoge in What are more accepted hypotheses that similarly explain the aspects of hominid evolution that the "pseudoscientific" aquatic ape theory does? by KEVLAR60442
The high surface area to volume ratio surprises me. Do we have any data on, say, averages across different species to compare to?
[deleted] t1_j9hiwkh wrote
Reply to comment by bonerfiedmurican in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
[removed]
[deleted] t1_j9hnytk wrote
Reply to comment by smellygooch18 in when a limb gets amputated, how do they stop the flow of blood? by EnchantedCatto
[removed]