Recent comments in /f/Music

audwun OP t1_jdduvta wrote

Nice recommendations! All have that dreamy quality. Some I’ve heard, love Gymnopedie No. 1, always wondered what it was when I’d hear it on the radio/tv etc. finally figured it out a couple years ago. My favorite band, deftones has a cover of Please, Please, Please Let Me Get What I Want. First time hearing the original I think, I like the og a lot more lol. Added a couple Floor Cry/Vansire tracks to my likes 🤙🏽

2

cynical_genx_man t1_jddttnz wrote

Well, here is where the subjectivity about music comes in, because when I hear them, Cale's version is understated which actually makes the lyrics more impactful, while when I hear Buckley it's almost as if he's trying too hard to give emotional resonance.

However, again, the fact is Cale's reworking of the lyrics was so profound that altering the song that it was a tectonic event. Buckley just sang it differently.

I don't think either of us is wrong, just different interpretations and reactions.

1

Opus-the-Penguin t1_jddshhk wrote

Yeah, but it's not. That's my point. Cale's making fine music but, for me, there's no connection to the words. He might as well be singing in a foreign language. He's Joan Sutherland and Buckley is Maria Callas.

Or to switch metaphors, Leonard Cohen's version is Moses--harsh and full of implied glory. Cale's is John the Baptist, preparing the way. But when the perfect comes, the partial must pass away.

1

cynical_genx_man t1_jddr4sw wrote

Cohen's second version (the more secular one) is the absolute best.

A close second is John Cale's version, because all of the others (including Buckley) are just basically carbon copies with nothing original to them whatsoever.

0